You’re browsing the 2012 version of this benchmark database. Head here for the most recent version.
Note: You have full access to this benchmark database in your Baymard Pro account.

Top 100 E-Commerce Checkouts

A usability benchmark of 100 e-commerce sites ranked by checkout usability performance

  • This benchmark database is based on usability reviews of 6,300 checkout elements on 100 sites across 6 themes.
  • Click on a site in the graph or the list to see its full checkout process and performance
  • Newer benchmark versions: 2016
  • Each site’s overall checkout usability is reflected in the list below while the scatterplot shows site score distributions within the 18 themes.
  • Tip: you can also navigate by checkout step type.

Crate & Barrel #1

Usability Score: 966

Pay special attention to their:

Layout

Navigation

+ 2 more pages

AutoZone #2

Usability Score: 948

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Flow

US Auto Parts #3

Usability Score: 930

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Navigation

Symantec #4

Usability Score: 923

Pay special attention to their:

Copywriting

Navigation

Cabela's #5

Usability Score: 903

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Copywriting

+ 2 more pages

American Eagle Outfitters #6

Usability Score: 869

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Data Input

+ 1 more pages

Sears #7

Usability Score: 865

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Layout

+ 2 more pages

Northern Tool #8

Usability Score: 856

Pay special attention to their:

Copywriting

Navigation

+ 2 more pages

Beachbody #9

Usability Score: 851

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Flow

Lowe's #10

Usability Score: 806

Pay special attention to their:

Copywriting

Data Input

+ 1 more pages

CafePress #11

Usability Score: 793

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Layout

1-800 Contacts #12

Usability Score: 770

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Flow

Home Depot #13

Usability Score: 759

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Data Input

+ 1 more pages

Eddie Bauer #14

Usability Score: 750

Pay special attention to their:

Copywriting

Layout

+ 1 more pages

Nordstrom #15

Usability Score: 735

Pay special attention to their:

Layout

Data Input

Victoria’s Secret #16

Usability Score: 723

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Copywriting

Hayneedle #17

Usability Score: 721

Pay special attention to their:

Layout

Data Input

Wayfair #18

Usability Score: 719

Pay special attention to their:

Copywriting

Layout

Blue Nile #19

Usability Score: 710

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Flow

+ 2 more pages

Neiman Marcus #20

Usability Score: 696

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Focus

Walmart #21

Usability Score: 690

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Navigation

+ 3 more pages

Coldwater Creek #22

Usability Score: 685

Pay special attention to their:

Flow

Navigation

+ 2 more pages

YOOX #23

Usability Score: 678

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Focus

+ 1 more pages

Amway #24

Usability Score: 669

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Flow

+ 2 more pages

Microsoft #25

Usability Score: 658

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Copywriting

Buy.com #26

Usability Score: 647

Pay special attention to their:

Copywriting

Flow

+ 1 more pages

Target #27

Usability Score: 647

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 1 more pages

Williams-Sonoma #28

Usability Score: 636

Pay special attention to their:

Layout

Flow

Musician's Friend #29

Usability Score: 636

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Data Input

+ 2 more pages

Aéropostale #30

Usability Score: 633

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Copywriting

+ 1 more pages

Drs. Foster & Smith #31

Usability Score: 624

Pay special attention to their:

Flow

Copywriting

+ 1 more pages

Gap #32

Usability Score: 620

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Navigation

+ 3 more pages

Nike #33

Usability Score: 618

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Data Input

+ 1 more pages

Apple #34

Usability Score: 615

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Navigation

+ 3 more pages

L.L. Bean #35

Usability Score: 602

Pay special attention to their:

Copywriting

Flow

+ 1 more pages

Kohl's #36

Usability Score: 588

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Copywriting

Gilt #37

Usability Score: 580

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Copywriting

+ 2 more pages

J&R #38

Usability Score: 575

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Navigation

REI #39

Usability Score: 568

Pay special attention to their:

Flow

Navigation

+ 1 more pages

Ancestry.com #40

Usability Score: 555

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Navigation

MLB #41

Usability Score: 546

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Data Input

+ 1 more pages

Tiffany #42

Usability Score: 530

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Navigation

+ 1 more pages

Harry and David #43

Usability Score: 526

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Navigation

+ 3 more pages

Disney Store #44

Usability Score: 514

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Navigation

Ralph Lauren #45

Usability Score: 512

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Layout

+ 1 more pages

eBags #46

Usability Score: 510

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Flow

+ 2 more pages

Walgreens #47

Usability Score: 483

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 3 more pages

Toys'R'Us #48

Usability Score: 474

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Layout

+ 1 more pages

Barnes & Noble #49

Usability Score: 474

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Navigation

+ 3 more pages

Ann Taylor #50

Usability Score: 467

Pay special attention to their:

Copywriting

Flow

YourSite.com #?

Want to know how your site would rank?

Get full access to rate your own site or have it audited by Baymard researchers.

Green Mountain Coffee #51

Usability Score: 465

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Data Input

+ 1 more pages

Macy’s #52

Usability Score: 456

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 2 more pages

Coastal Contacts #53

Usability Score: 434

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Data Input

FTD #54

Usability Score: 434

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Flow

Crutchfield #55

Usability Score: 431

Pay special attention to their:

Navigation

Data Input

Nutrisystem #56

Usability Score: 429

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Layout

GameStop #57

Usability Score: 422

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 1 more pages

HP #58

Usability Score: 422

Pay special attention to their:

Layout

Navigation

+ 2 more pages

Staples #59

Usability Score: 418

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Layout

Rue La La #60

Usability Score: 413

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Flow

FreshDirect #61

Usability Score: 398

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Flow

+ 2 more pages

Blockbuster #62

Usability Score: 355

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Data Input

+ 1 more pages

Net-a-Porter #63

Usability Score: 350

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Data Input

+ 1 more pages

Football Fanatics #64

Usability Score: 339

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Layout

Zones #65

Usability Score: 332

Pay special attention to their:

Layout

Copywriting

Dell #66

Usability Score: 332

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Data Input

+ 2 more pages

Foot Locker #67

Usability Score: 330

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 3 more pages

1-800-Flowers #68

Usability Score: 317

Pay special attention to their:

Flow

Copywriting

CVS #69

Usability Score: 310

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 1 more pages

Build.com #70

Usability Score: 303

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Copywriting

J.C. Penney #71

Usability Score: 290

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Navigation

+ 1 more pages

Restoration Hardware #72

Usability Score: 274

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Layout

Vitacost #73

Usability Score: 270

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 3 more pages

Amazon #74

Usability Score: 265

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Flow

+ 4 more pages

drugstore.com #75

Usability Score: 263

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Layout

Sephora #76

Usability Score: 252

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 4 more pages

CDW #77

Usability Score: 247

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Data Input

+ 1 more pages

Sony #78

Usability Score: 247

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 4 more pages

Shoebuy.com #79

Usability Score: 245

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Copywriting

Office Depot #80

Usability Score: 229

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Copywriting

+ 1 more pages

American Girl #81

Usability Score: 220

Pay special attention to their:

Copywriting

Data Input

+ 3 more pages

OfficeMax #82

Usability Score: 184

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Copywriting

+ 1 more pages

PetMeds #83

Usability Score: 168

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Copywriting

Bass Pro Shops #84

Usability Score: 168

Pay special attention to their:

Layout

Copywriting

+ 2 more pages

Scholastic #85

Usability Score: 155

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

Diapers.com #86

Usability Score: 148

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 1 more pages

Best Buy #87

Usability Score: 103

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 3 more pages

J.Crew #88

Usability Score: 97

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 2 more pages

Overstock.com #89

Usability Score: 94

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

Peapod #90

Usability Score: 85

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Data Input

+ 4 more pages

PC Connection #91

Usability Score: 83

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Copywriting

+ 2 more pages

Avon #92

Usability Score: 43

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Data Input

PC Mall #93

Usability Score: 7

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Layout

+ 2 more pages

Talbots #94

Usability Score: -27

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Flow

+ 1 more pages

Safeway #95

Usability Score: -43

Pay special attention to their:

Flow

Layout

+ 5 more pages

Market America #96

Usability Score: -85

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Data Input

+ 3 more pages

ShopNBC #97

Usability Score: -117

Pay special attention to their:

Focus

Data Input

+ 5 more pages

Newegg #98

Usability Score: -202

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

Costco #99

Usability Score: -296

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 1 more pages

Grainger #100

Usability Score: -544

Pay special attention to their:

Data Input

Focus

+ 5 more pages
Close overlay