Consumables Subscriptions

Consumables Subscription UX Research

Explore how people understand and evaluate subscriptions for physical products. Baymard’s research covers product boxes, grocery boxes and related recurring purchases, with findings on presenting the offer, choosing products, signing up and managing the ongoing account experience.

Book a demo call

Research the decision to subscribe, as well as the products

A subscription asks customers to understand an ongoing arrangement. They need to know how the service works, what they can choose and what follows signup. This research focuses on that buying model across physical products, while related industry studies provide more detailed guidance for grocery, beauty, apparel and other categories.

Examples of consumables subscription websites studied by Baymard

Key UX challenges for consumables subscription

Explaining how the service works

See how a layered information structure helps people move from a short subscription overview to detailed answers, without overwhelming first-time visitors with every detail.

Read the research

Making the next step understandable

Read why subscription calls to action need to match the step that follows, helping people understand whether they are exploring options or starting signup.

Read the research

Understanding subscription expectations

Explore findings from testing physical-product subscription services, including how people evaluate the offering and the information they seek before deciding whether to subscribe.

Read the research

Consumables subscription research, in numbers

These figures describe the current consumables subscription research collection.

380+

Consumables subscription UX guidelines

3,100+

Consumables subscription UX performance scores

2,300+

Consumables subscription best practice examples

Consumables Subscription Services

The findings from Baymard’s large-scale testing of Consumables Subscription Services websites provide you with 380+ UX guidelines, along with 3,100+ UX performance scores and 2,300+ best practice examples from Consumables Subscription Services sites.

This research study on ‘Consumables Subscription Service’ websites cover sites that sell subscriptions for physical products that users consume or deplete on a regular basis – be it grocery box subscriptions, meal kits, office supplies, health & beauty, fashion, etc.
The focus of this UX research study is specifically on how users react, evaluate, and make a purchasing decision on websites that sell physical products on a subscription basis.

The research includes Consumables Subscription Services websites such as:
- Product Subscriptions: Rent the Runway, Dollar Shave Club, Birchbox, Book of the Month, BarkBox, Bespoke Post, and KiwiCo.
- Grocery Box Subcriptions: Imperfect Foods, Hungryroot, Farm To People, ButcherBox, Crowd Cow, Oceanbox, and Sea to Table.
- Meal Kits: Blue Apron, Dinnerly, Gobble, HelloFresh, Home Chef, Sunbasket, Marley Spoon, Purple Carrot, Green Chef, Gousto, and Abel & Cole.
8 × Themes

How the consumables subscription research was conducted

This study focuses on subscriptions for physical products that customers consume or replace, including product boxes, grocery boxes and meal kits. Usability testing includes services such as Hungryroot, ButcherBox and HelloFresh, examining how people understand the offer and assess a recurring purchase.

The public consumables subscription benchmark covers eight services, including Birchbox, Book of the Month, BarkBox and Dollar Shave Club. Researchers record how research-based UX criteria are implemented and connect performance scores with examples from desktop and mobile websites.

The findings also draw on Baymard’s wider ecommerce research, including moderated think-aloud testing. Related industry studies add product-specific detail, helping teams connect the recurring-service experience with the kinds of products included in their subscription.

Read about the study

Read our research methodology

Explore consumables subscription UX benchmarks

Browse examples from physical-product subscription services including BarkBox, Birchbox and Book of the Month. The benchmark offers a concrete way to explore recurring-purchase experiences, while a demo can show how subscription findings connect with the product research relevant to your service.

Book a demo call

Browse consumables subscription UX benchmarks

Illustration of Baymard consumables subscription UX benchmarking and site comparisons

How teams use Baymard’s research

Testimonials
Boxed Logo
“Here at Boxed we’re a small team who are BIG fans of your research. Your services have been immensely helpful to us as a small UX/UI team, and we are so excited to have a new version of our own product page going into development later this month.”

Jillian Crudo

Product Design Manager at Boxed

Testimonials
Keurig Green Mountain Logo
“I have found the M-Commerce and E-Commerce reports very useful, thank you!”

Josh Shaw

Web Manager at Keurig Green Mountain

Testimonials
Integer Logo
“My team loves Baymard Premium and it has become a valuable tool for us. We consult with a number of large brands and manage their eComm (both DTC and eRetail) and your data is amazing, it gives us all the testing data without having to run the tests ourselves. Our clients appreciate us having the depth of knowledge Baymard provides, we’ve used Baymard data multiple times to defend our recommendations and to inform our designs.”

Dean Rizzuto

UX Director at Integer Group

Looking for an expert review of your site?

Baymard’s UX audit service can review the subscription journeys and site areas relevant to your service.

Explore consumables subscription UX audits

See the consumables subscription research in action

Book a demo to explore how the guidelines, examples and benchmarks can support your consumables subscription UX decisions.

Compare research access options